Select language, opens an overlay
  • General Recommendations
  • Patron-Created List

Mock Caldecott 2021

This is a place where I read and rate Caldecott eligible picture books published in 2020. I will try to predict the real 2021 medal and honorees too!

Vancouver Public Library

34 items

  • BookNew York : Orchard Books, an imprint of Scholastic, Inc., 2020. — J FIC EASY
  • Wonderfully written, fantastic endnotes, just lovely. I think it has a shot at the Newbery to be totally honest. I think the illustrations are great but can't see this one nabbing the Caldecott even though I am totally here for Ekua to win…
    BookNew York, NY : Roaring Brook Press, 2020. — J+FIC
  • This is a really sweet book and I do love illustrated poems. This is a picture book version of Johnson's 2004 poem A Girl Like Me. It's a funny, charming, and powerful poem while the illustrations feature photographs of young, mostly…
    eBookLerner Publishing Group, 2020.
  • I read the e-book version and thought it quite sweet, lovely illustrations and a nice warm feel to the parent-child outing. As a wordless book, it definitely tells the story of their day quite well but I didn't feel that sense of wonder…
    eBookCandlewick Press.
  • BookNew York : Atheneum Books for Young Readers, [2020] — J+FIC
  • Okay this one has some potential - it has a whole lot going for it in terms of the Caldecott criteria and I for one would not be surprised to see it on the slate - more likely an honor than the gold given the competition this year but yes,…
    BookNew York, NY : Norton Young Readers, an imprint of W. W. Norton and Company, [2020] — J+FIC
  • I can see this book getting Coretta Scott King love obviously, and it is really, really great so maybe...but I just don't think the illustrations can compete with some others this year.
    BookNew York : Holiday House, [2020] — J FIC EASY
  • Well besides making me super hungry for all the food, I wasn't in love with this one - the story is too weak. I think the cartoon-y illustration style is well rendered and certainly think it hits across a few criteria pretty well but as…
    BookBoston : Versify, an imprint of Houghton Mifflin Harcourt, [2020] — SPA J+FIC
  • I read the e-book. I think this one has a lot going for it and would put it in my strong contender pile. I am totally here for Christian Robinson winning the gold some day and maybe this is his year! It is a simple ode to children (and I…
    eBookSimon and Schuster, Incorporated, 2020.
  • Packs

    Strength in Numbers

    Salyer, Hannah
    eBookHoughton Mifflin Harcourt Trade and Reference, 2020.
  • Yes, yes, a thousand times yes. I am behind this book getting to the slate. It is superlative in every way and hits high across all criteria. Wow, how awesome would it be to have an Indigenous Caldecott medalist? Illustrated AND written by…
    BookNew York, NY : Roaring Brook Press, 2020. — J+FIC
  • BookBoston : Houghton Mifflin Harcourt, [2020] — J+FIC
  • BookBoston ; New York : Houghton Mifflin Harcourt, [2020] — J+FIC